The workers were loaded onto planes back home.
    More recently, in 2000 in Leamington, Ontario, a group of
Mexicans brought in under the Canadian guest worker program stopped
work, protesting abuse by a foreman on a local farm.  Sixteen workers
were deported as a result.
    The H2-A program establishes a wage rate, which is supposed
to be a minimum, currently a little over $7/hour in most areas.  "But
if workers demand more," Goldstein says, "the employer can say, 'I'm
offering all that the Department of Labor requires.  If you don't
like it, I can get more workers.'  In effect, the minimum standard
becomes the maximum standard.  You could even have a union for
braceros, but in this system, it would have no bargaining power.  The
Department says you can't fill a vacancy created by a strike with a
guest worker, but they define this so narrowly that it's virtually
impossible to enforce."
    Despite the low wages and bad conditions, however, Garcia did
eventually manage to find an employer who was different.  And because
of that, he was able to become a permanent legal resident.
    "In San Diego I worked for a Japanese grower named Suzuki, a
good man," he remembers.  "During the war they had put him into one
of the camps. He told us, 'I know what your life is like, because we
lived that way too, in concentration camps, watched over with
rifles.'  So he got papers for all of us, and told us to come work
with him.  That was the last contract I worked."
    Some growers in Canada, Goldstein says, even go to the
Mexican towns from which their workers come to attend the local
fiesta.  One New Hampshire apple grower attempted to take over the
local growers' association to raise the wages for H2-A workers, only
to wind up losing his own seat on the group's board.  "Occasionally
there is a person who wants to be fair," he says, "but the economic
forces at work are too powerful.  You can't really go against them."
    And why should workers have to rely on the benevolence of
their employers anyway?
    The answer unions give to the vulnerable state of immigrant
farm workers is amnesty -- a legalization program which would allow
those who are undocumented to gain legal status.  According to a
recent study by the Pew Hispanic Center, 47% of  all farm workers
lack papers -- about 1.25 million people.  Counting their families,
that number is even higher.  The same study says there are about 7.8
million undocumented immigrants in the country as a whole, and in
urban areas, they make up almost 4% of the entire workforce.
    In 1986, after the amnesty program of the Immigration Reform
and Control Act took effect, over 3 million people gained legal
status.  The act, with its special provision for farm workers, had a
big effect on union organizing among immigrants.  As people lost
their fear of deportation, and employers lost their ability to
threaten workers with it, an upsurge in strikes and organizing drives
swept through Los Angeles and areas of the country where immigrants
are concentrated.  One strike alone, among the workers who hang
drywall in new homes, shut down home construction throughout southern
California for most of 1992.  The 1986 amnesty set the stage for the
war to regain contracts among Los Angeles janitors, chronicled in the
movie Bread and Roses.
    The strategy of farm worker unions, therefore, has been to
get a new amnesty, which would aid those workers presently in the
fields to organize and win better conditions.  Even if the present. [Continue....]

Back to News in USA