because what happened to him could happen to any of us.  They said
they'd left soap on the plates, because lots of others got diarrhea.
I got it too.  But this boy died."
    According to Goldstein, for current H2-A workers "things have
improved here a little.  Today workers complain that the food often
isn't culturally appropriate, but no one's dying of food poisoning.
But if a much larger guest worker system is reestablished, it really
would look like what we had during the bracero program.  How else
could they manage such a workforce?  And for the H2-A's, it already
exists.""
    US farm workers and their unions fear guest workers because
of the way braceros were used to replace resident workers in during
the program's 22 year history, from 1942-1964.  "The growers are
lobbying for a new guest worker law on the grounds that there is not
enough labor available," says Lucas Benitez of the Coalition of
Immokalee Workers, a community-based project organizing farm workers
in south Florida.  "But it's a lie.  Everyday in the papers you read
about the high numbers of unemployed workers.  The problem is that
most workers in this country do not want to do the work we do for
wages we're paid.  We average seven thousand five hundred dollars a
year and the conditions of exploitation are such that any reasonable
person would prefer receiving unemployment benefits.  The answer to
the guest worker lobbying effort is to raise wages and improve
working conditions."
    During the 1950s, growers brought in braceros when their
existing workforce struck, or threatened to do so.  That threat
allowed them to undermine the ability of the farm workers of that era
to demand higher wages.  In the late 1950s and early 1960s, Cesar
Chavez, then an organizer for the Community Service Organization in
Oxnard, California, mounted farm worker protests over the program.
He later said that organizing the United Farm Workers would have been
impossible had it not been halted in 1964.  In fact, the great grape
strike in which the union was born began the following year.
    But braceros did not always willingly acquiesce in their
exploitation.  California's legendary immigrant rights campaigner,
Bert Corona, recalls in his autobiography not only that braceros
sometimes went on strike, but that local Latino communities would
bring them food and try to prevent their deportation.
    Garcia also remembers strikes.  "The foremen really abused
people," he says.  "A lot was expected of you, and they always
demanded even more.  But there were places where braceros stopped
work.  One of my brothers went on strike in Phoenix because they were
picking cotton and the crop was bad.  They threatened to send them
back to Mexico, and put them on a bus to El Centro. My brother, one
of the leaders, got strikes into his blood, and later worked with
Cesar Chavez for many years.  Me too. When the farm workers' movement
came along, we already knew how to organize from people who'd
participated in those conflicts."
    But while some braceros may have fought to change conditions,
and small rebellions may have raised the wages temporarily, the
threat of deportation was enough to stop any larger strike and union
effort until 1965.
    Rebellions among H2-A workers aren't unknown either.  In
1986, Jamaican sugar cane workers in Florida stopped work to try to
raise the piece rate.  Growers called in the sheriffs, who sicced
dogs on the strikers, and the dispute became known as the Dog Wars.         [Continue]

Back to News in USA